Robert Clarke '81, who took 2.626/7 while enrolled in MIT's professional education program, says his group hoped to determine the efficiencies of PV modules under actual operating conditions: "We wanted to look at real modules in the field, not theoretical ones." Peter Cooper, manager of sustainability engineering and utility planning at MIT Facilities, helped the team extract years of performance data from the solar installations' computer monitoring system, which, in Cooper's words, was "not user-friendly."
After long hours of analysis and late-night meetings, Clarke says, the students were able to characterize the energy output of these installations for a six-year period, which they then compared to the systems' peak energy ratings. The team detected greater losses of efficiency than expected, and tracked down the causes, which included orientation of the panels on the roofs, dirt, snow and shading. To the surprise of utility managers, the students also discovered that the systems intermittently failed altogether. These shutdowns at times went unnoticed because the PV installations lacked real-time operational alerts to managers.
The team's final report is "the first comprehensive look at our installations," Cooper says, and one that is "terrifically informative." While Cooper notes that PV-generated electricity makes up less than 1 percent of MIT's overall energy capacity — the largest system, on the Alumni Pool, was installed in part to offset electricity used to relight the Great Dome — the PV arrays "advance learning and education around renewable energy on campus." The students' project, he says, fits right in with MIT's goal of "trying and learning new things about energy," as well as "developing expertise about what our systems can and can't do."
In practical terms, the study also helps MIT prioritize ways of improving PV performance, whether by cleaning and reorienting panels or launching a real-time alert system to flag PV failures. And when the time comes for the next installation of solar panels, Cooper says, "we will be looking at this report to optimize all of the components they studied."
This article first appeared in the Spring 2011 issue of Energy Futures, the magazine of the MIT Energy Initiative.