Skip to content ↓

Kids gain more from family than foster care

Press Inquiries

Press Contact:

Paul Denning
Phone: 617-253-0576
MIT Sloan School of Management

Media Download

Joseph J. Doyle Jr.
Download Image
Caption: Joseph J. Doyle Jr.

*Terms of Use:

Images for download on the MIT News office website are made available to non-commercial entities, press and the general public under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives license. You may not alter the images provided, other than to crop them to size. A credit line must be used when reproducing images; if one is not provided below, credit the images to "MIT."

Close
Joseph J. Doyle Jr.
Caption:
Joseph J. Doyle Jr.

An MIT Sloan School of Management professor has for the first time used the analytic tools of applied economics to show that children faced with two options - being allowed to stay at home or being placed into foster care - have generally better life outcomes when they remain with their families.
 
"While much has been written about the trade-off between family preservation and child protection, little empirical work has been able to support a greater emphasis on either one," said Joseph Doyle Jr., assistant professor of applied economics at Sloan. "My research suggests that children on the margin of foster care placement have better employment, delinquency, and teen motherhood outcomes when they remain at home."
 
Doyle, the Jon D. Gruber Career Development Assistant Professor of Applied Economics, said his study is the first to empirically demonstrate causal effects between placement decisions and long-term outcomes. "The child welfare system directly impacts millions of children at risk of poor life outcomes each year, yet much of the previous evidence on the effect of foster care on outcomes looked at correlations, not causal effects," he said. "But if you find that 28 percent of homeless people were once in foster care, it doesn't mean they are homeless because of foster care."
 
To establish a causal effect, Doyle analyzed a unique dataset that links children investigated by Illinois's child protection agency with a range of government programs. To control for variable factors in placement decisions-- such as the possibility that worse outcomes for foster children were due to worse family backgrounds -- Doyle based his analysis on random assignments of cases to social workers. Because cases in Illinois are assigned on a rotational basis and child characteristics were found to be similar across investigators, Doyle was able to study a representative range of children involved in the system, some of whom stayed with their families, while others were placed into foster care.
 
 "We were able to analyze what would have happened to a child if he or she had stayed at home, rather than in a foster home," he said. "For decades, the issue of family preservation versus foster placement has been a thorny one. In the 1960s, the number of children in foster care increased from 200,000 to 600,000, and then fell back to 200,000 by 1980. Currently, more than 500,000 children are in care and we're again seeing an emphasis on family preservation."
 
But if keeping children who stay with their families generally fare better, that will mean a greater need for services to help keep families intact. "Our research generally supports the current direction toward family preservation," said Doyle. "Future research should consider an even wider set of childhood outcomes."

Press Mentions

The Washington Post

In an article for The Washington Post about foster care, Max Ehrenfreund highlights Prof. Joseph J. Doyle’s study examining the long-term impacts of foster care. Doyle found that “while many children must be removed for their safety, investigators often do better by kids when they give parents the benefit of the doubt.”

Related Links

Related Topics

More MIT News

Photo of Annauk Olin with her husband and baby

Saving Iñupiaq

Linguistics graduate student Annauk Olin is helping her Alaska Native community preserve their language and navigate the severe impact of climate change.

Read full story