Skip to content ↓

Stu Schmill endorses report on consideration of character in college admissions

Dean of MIT Admissions joins peers in recommending increased consideration of prospective students’ concern for others in college admissions.
Press Inquiries

Press Contact:

Kris Guay
Phone: 617-258-5523
MIT Undergraduate Admissions
Kimberly Allen
Phone: 617-253-2702
Fax: 617-258-8762
MIT News Office
Close
Dean of MIT Admissions Stu Schmill speaks with The Today Show host Matt Lauer on the new "Turning the Tide" report on college admissions.
Caption:
Dean of MIT Admissions Stu Schmill speaks with The Today Show host Matt Lauer on the new "Turning the Tide" report on college admissions.
Credits:
Image: NBC

During the past year, Dean of MIT Admissions Stu Schmill has been part of a working group hosted by the Making Caring Common project at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. The group, including college deans, guidance counselors, and other key stakeholders, has considered how to promote ethical character and achieve greater fairness and integrity in the college admissions process.

On Wednesday, the outcome of the group's work was released at an event at the New York Public Library in Manhattan. The resulting report, "Turning the Tide: Inspiring Concern for Others and the Common Good through College Admissions," was endorsed by 80 college admissions professionals and other stakeholders. 

The group began discussions with the premise that colleges, and specifically admissions processes, send messages about what colleges — and our society at large — value. These messages, in turn, ultimately end up influencing the behavior of millions of students.

The findings of the report advance a widely shared vision that college admissions can and should align their messages to convey the idea that concern for others and the common good should not take a back seat to personal achievement and intellectual engagement.

The report offers specific recommendations for reforming the admissions process in each of the following three areas:

  • promoting more meaningful contributions to others, community service, and engagement with the public good;
  • assessing students’ ethical character and contributions to others in ways that reflect varying types of family and community contributions across race, culture, and class; and
  • redefining achievement in ways that both level the playing field for economically diverse students and reduce excessive achievement pressure.

“I think it is an important report and have signed on as an ‘endorser’ along with many of my colleagues around the country, including all of the Ivy League deans,” Schmill says. “In fact, we already do many of the items suggested in the paper.”

This year, the MIT Admissions Office changed one of the required essay questions on MIT’s undergraduate application to reflect its commitment to students’ contributions to the public good — something that aligns well with the MIT mission. The application question now asks:

“At MIT, we seek to develop in each member of our community the ability and passion to work collaboratively for the betterment of humankind. How have you improved the lives of others in your community? (This could be one person or many, at school or at home, in your neighborhood or your state, etc.)”

With respect to the recommendations for reducing academic performance pressures, MIT Admissions has long taken an active role in promoting the messages of “finding your fit” in college, both through its holistic selection process and in many recruitment communications. MIT Admissions led the way more than 10 years ago by reducing the number of spaces for extracurricular activities on its application, sending the message to applicants that quality is more important than quantity.

The new 17-page report of recommendations concludes with the notion that too often colleges, high schools, and parents are competing in an “arms race” that is costly both to young people and to our society and that those involved in admissions work with others to “hold up, expect and honor in young people a more ethical and meaningful way of leading a life.”

“The hope is that with many colleges and universities sending the same message to students,” Schmill says, “we might make a difference in what students pursue in high school — and bring a little more sanity back into it, with a focus on what is truly important.”

For more information, visit: makingcaringcommon.org.

Press Mentions

WBUR

Stuart Schmill, MIT’s dean of admissions, speaks with WBUR’s Fred Thys about why colleges are placing an increased emphasis on the whole student as opposed to extracurricular activities. “We want students to take the most challenging classes that are most appropriate for them,” says Schmill, “but they don't need to do that in every single subject.”

Boston Globe

In an article for The Boston Globe, Linda Wertheimer writes about “Turning the Tide,” a new report that aims to focus the college admissions process on the whole student. “The right thing is not to overdo it, not to have this push for quantity over quality,” explains MIT Dean of Admissions Stuart Schmill.

WRKO

Dean of Admissions Stuart Schmill speaks with WRKO’s Kim Carrigan about a new set of recommendations for the college admissions process. Schmill explains that, “we want students who are going to come here and try to improve the lives of their classmates,” as well as students interested in having a positive effect on the world.

The Wall Street Journal

In an article for The Wall Street Journal, Leslie Brody speaks with Stuart Schmill, dean of admissions, about a report that recommends new guidelines for the college admissions process. “We want students to lead balanced lives,” says Schmill of the impetus for updating the admissions process. 

New York Times

New York Times columnist Frank Bruni examines “Turning the Tide,” a new report that recommends changes to the college admissions process. Bruni says the report - which Stuart Schmill, dean of admissions, contributed to – “sagely reflects on what’s wrong with admissions and rightly calls for a revolution, including specific suggestions.”

Today Show

Stu Schmill, MIT’s Dean of Admissions, speaks with Matt Lauer of The Today Show about a new report that he helped develop, which recommends changes in the college application process. “This report, I hope, will really send a more powerful message around what colleges are really, really interested to see,” says Schmill. 

Related Links

Related Topics

Related Articles

More MIT News

Photo of five people seated on a stage with the MITEI logo in the background

Making hydrogen power a reality

Hydrogen fuel has long been seen as a potentially key component of a carbon-neutral future. At the 2022 MIT Energy Initiative Spring Symposium, industry experts describe efforts to produce it at scale.

Read full story